I can see clearly now the rain is gone. These immortal words by the great Jimmy Cliff resonate with me and the hundreds of supervisors I have shared this powerful insight about leadership. The truth is, most supervisors still believe in and adopt the approach for control rather than influence. It is not their fault. We have been using the same model for management since the early 1900s. This carrot and the stick methodology is management 1.0. What if there is a
better way? What if there is an easier way? What if there is a more powerful way to get desired behaviors from your teams? Enter choice architecture.
As we begin to reopen our attitude toward business and Covid-19, consider the tremendous opportunity to use this historical moment as a pivot point for leadership in your organization. We are watching power-hungry politicians attempt to control a human population (in America) who have freedom at our core. Civil
liberties are being sacrificed in the name of remaining safe from a virus. Some politicians are getting tremendous resistance because they are attempting to usemanagement 1.0 (carrot and stick) instead of choice architecture to gain desired behavior. They are failing. If we do experience a second wave of coronavirus, Americans will not be locked-down again. If you desire more opinion on this, you can listen to my podcast, “Crazy Enough to Win” on all major podcasting platforms. This debate is not the point of this article.
The same results are occurring for supervisors and managers all over
the world. The old prescription for management is being revealed for the inefficacy that always existed. There is a better way. A more effective method to gain compliance or desired behavior is the gentle nudge that is the result of choice architecture. I have been teaching and training supervisors, managers, and executives these concepts since discovering the work of Richard Thaler and Cass Sunsteinin 2008. In the highly-recommend book “Nudge”, these behavioral economists call choice architecture the practice of influencing choice by “organizing the context in which people make decisions”. Ironically, the book was written as we entered the 2008-2009 financial crisis, so the applicability of this work is timely as we recover from this pandemic. How cool is that?
No credible definition of leadership is missing
the word influence. The essence of leadership is influence. The essence of management is control. Choice architecture is rooted in influence of other people rather than control. Arranging food a certain way in the cafeteria to get people to make healthier choices is a common example of choice architecture. The same thinking can be applied to all facets of human existence, including supervisors at work. I amgoing to share a few examples in this article so you can see and understand the value for your leadership team. For the past twelve years, I have honed and crafted these tools for manufacturing, healthcare, non-profit, petrochemical, and energy sectors to name a few.
Aspiring leaders (aka managers and supervisors) may use default options as a gentle nudge for team members. Here is an example, not a recommendation, so you will understand the point. I am not an investment
advisor. If a manager desires more participation in the company 401K match, she may consider defaulting to accomplish this outcome. In other words, instead of giving employees the option, she subtly sets the default as “in” and theymust“opt-out” in order to not participate. Defaulting is also effective in terms of employee safety and productivity on the job.
A second tool in choice architecture is framing. Behavioral options might be presented in a way that highlights the positive or negative aspects of the same decision. This can lead to changes in their relative attractiveness and as a result, employee behavior. In safety management, this might be when a manager highlights a high
compliance rate instead of placing emphasis on the few people that are out of compliance. In production terms, framing can be the focus onthose who succeed rather than those who fail.
Using decoys to encourage behavior is another example of choice architecture. With Covid-19 in the background, a supervisor might post the number of cases (or deaths) in the community next to an automatic hand sanitizer dispenser by the break room exit in a manufacturing plant. The decoy is the posting that reminds employees to clean hands before returning to work.
These are just examples to make the point for the use of choice architecture more deliberately as a tool to lead people in the workplace. It already exits all around us in obvious and more subtle ways. Flashing lights on a rural country road is an example to nudge a driver to slow down. Aspiring leaders can learn to adopt this management 2.0 approach in order to gain desired behavior. When taught properly, choice architecture opens an incalculable number of options for
supervisors and managers. I have heard comments from students like, “I was blind, now I can see” and “Wow, this makes my job easier”.
Choice architecture is deeply rooted in behavioral economics. Richard Thaler won a Nobel Prize in this field of study. The key to success is taking...
Discover My Podcast
Leading the Tribes Video
Leading the Tribes Training - Book my 1-day class at your location for managers and supervisors.
Leading the Tribes Keynote Speech - Book my 1-hour speech for your event.
Call (903) 295-7400 Today!
Keeping Top Talent Video
Need a Keynote Speaker?
I'm always amazed at how fun you can make learning!
Tessa Conrad, Pak-Sher
Your excitement and energy as a speaker is amazing. Hearing you speak on your years of experience and insights on leadership and generational change was very relevant and something that we can all learn from and apply to our organizations.
Cliff McDaniel, Louisiana CPA Oil and Gas Conference
It was the best presentation that I have attended so far, You are the best speaker ever . I am so impressed that I have ordered 2 of your books on Amazon. So thank you for making a difference in people’s personal and professional lives.
Lovely Chandla, Hilton
John Grubbs' keynote message is powerful! John is able to clearly convey his knowledge and foresight on the generational changes that affect ALL of us. I had many A-ha moments with his vivid examples. We continue to talk about what his message taught us to this day. You will have to reach for a tissue to wipe tears of emotion and laughter. John's message is memorable and inspirational!
Maria Gallegos, Texas Chemical Council
Call John Grubbs (903) 295-7400